The Demise of VMware: How an Industry Titan Lost Its Way

VMware, once the undisputed king of virtualization, has seen its reign challenged in recent years. While the company basked in the glory of market dominance in the mid-2000s, a series of missteps and the controversial acquisition by Broadcom have left a cloud of uncertainty hanging over its future. 

This article delves deep into the factors that contributed to VMware’s decline, focusing on the impact of Broadcom’s ownership and the company’s exorbitant licensing costs compared to its competitors.

The Rise of a Virtualization Giant

The story of VMware’s rise begins in the mainframe era of the 1960s. Back then, these massive computers could only handle one process at a time. As demand grew for these expensive machines to support multiple users and processes, the concept of virtualization emerged¹. Fast forward to the mid-2000s, and VMware was at the forefront of the virtualization revolution, bringing this concept to the x86 server market. Its innovative products, such as VMware Workstation, GSX Server, and ESX Server, allowed businesses to consolidate their IT infrastructure, reduce hardware costs, and improve operational efficiency².

VMware’s vSphere platform, with its ESXi hypervisor, quickly became the industry standard⁴. The company’s success was fueled by its strong focus on research and development, a commitment to providing cutting-edge solutions, and a thriving partner ecosystem⁵. This commitment to innovation was evident in VMware’s early partnership with Nicira, a company pioneering software-defined networking. This collaboration led to the development of NSX, a network virtualization platform that extended VMware’s reach into the software-defined data center⁶.

During this period, VMware’s dominance was virtually unchallenged. Even Microsoft’s attempt to compete with Hyper-V, a bundled alternative to vSphere, failed to make a significant dent in VMware’s impressive market share, which reached a staggering 97% of the virtualization software market revenue⁴. VMware continued to innovate with solutions like vMotion and Virtual SMP technology, further solidifying its position as the leader in the virtualization space⁷.

Broadcom’s Playbook

Before diving into the impact of Broadcom’s acquisition, it’s crucial to understand their typical approach to acquiring and managing companies. Broadcom, a global technology leader in semiconductor and infrastructure software solutions, has a history of aggressive acquisitions⁸. Their business model revolves around a strong emphasis on research and development, allowing them to stay ahead of the curve⁹. However, their acquisition strategy often involves streamlining and consolidating product offerings to maximize profitability¹⁰.

Broadcom’s strategy with VMware appears to be no different. They have publicly stated their intention to focus on a select group of large customers, primarily those in highly regulated industries who are less likely to switch providers¹¹. This targeted approach allows them to reduce sales and marketing costs while potentially increasing revenue from these key accounts.

The Broadcom Acquisition: A Turning Point

The landscape shifted dramatically in November 2023 when Broadcom acquired VMware for $61 billion⁴. While Broadcom initially assured stakeholders that they would maintain VMware’s core technologies and customer focus, emphasizing their commitment to investing in research and development and meeting customer needs, the reality has been quite different¹².

Licensing Changes

One of the most significant changes was the shift from perpetual licenses to a subscription-based licensing model¹⁴. This move, coupled with the consolidation of VMware’s extensive product offerings into just two main bundles – VMware Cloud Foundation and VMware vSphere Foundation – resulted in substantial price increases for many customers¹⁶. Some customers even reported receiving renewal quotes that were 10-15 times higher than their previous contracts¹⁸. To encourage the transition, Broadcom offered trade-in incentives and discounts for customers willing to switch to the new subscription model¹⁹. However, these incentives have not been enough to quell the concerns of many customers.

This transition to subscription-based licensing has significant long-term financial implications. For customers, it means moving from a one-time capital expenditure to a recurring operational expense, potentially straining IT budgets²⁰. For VMware, it creates a more predictable revenue stream, but it also risks alienating customers who prefer the flexibility and control of perpetual licenses²¹.

Product Consolidation

In addition to licensing changes, Broadcom significantly streamlined VMware’s product portfolio. Many standalone products were discontinued, including the free vSphere Hypervisor and the vSphere Essentials bundle²². This consolidation has further reduced customer choice and flexibility, forcing them into bundled packages that may include features they don’t need or want.

Customer Impact

The impact of these changes has been significant. Customers have expressed concerns about the lack of flexibility, the increased costs, and the potential for vendor lock-in²³. Cloud service providers, in particular, have voiced concerns about the impact on their business models, as many rely heavily on VMware’s virtualization technologies²³. Furthermore, concerns have been raised about the future of VMware Cloud on AWS, as Broadcom has restricted AWS and its partners from reselling it and has made it impossible to port existing perpetual licenses to the cloud¹⁸.

Partner Ecosystem Disruption

Broadcom’s acquisition also disrupted VMware’s partner ecosystem. Existing partner agreements were terminated, requiring resellers and service providers to reapply under a new program¹⁵. This move has caused uncertainty and disruption for many partners who relied on VMware’s established channel programs.

Organizational Restructuring and Potential for Audits

Internally, VMware underwent significant organizational restructuring, with employees facing new roles and reporting lines within Broadcom²⁴. This restructuring, coupled with Broadcom’s focus on maximizing revenue, has led to concerns about increased license audits, similar to the practices of other companies like Oracle²⁵.

Focus on Strategic Customers

Broadcom’s strategy of concentrating on a smaller number of large customers has raised concerns about the level of support and attention that smaller customers will receive²⁶. This approach could further alienate a significant portion of VMware’s customer base and create opportunities for competitors who are willing to cater to the needs of smaller businesses.

The Price of Progress: Licensing Costs Compared to Competitors

VMware’s licensing costs have become a major pain point for customers, especially when compared to its competitors. While VMware vSphere Enterprise Plus costs $4,780 per CPU per year, alternative solutions like Red Hat Virtualization and Oracle Linux Virtualization Manager offer more flexible subscription-based approaches at potentially lower costs²⁷. Open-source solutions like Proxmox VE, with no initial licensing costs, are also gaining traction among budget-conscious organizations²⁸.

The table below provides a comparison of VMware’s licensing costs with those of its competitors:

Product	Licensing Model	Cost	Notes
VMware vSphere Enterprise Plus	Per CPU, per year	$4,780 27
vSphere Essentials Kit		$1,319 29 \$	\

In contrast to VMware’s pricing, here’s a look at the cost and scalability of some of its competitors:

Feature/Aspect	Citrix Hypervisor	Microsoft Hyper-V	Oracle VirtualBox	Red Hat Virtualization	Proxmox VE	KVM	Nutanix
Cost	Generally lower than VMware, but still requires a subscription	Included with Windows Server	Open-source, free with optional support plans	Subscription-based, lower than VMware	Free with optional support plans	Free and open-source	Subscription-based, with per-node or per-VM pricing 31
Scalability	Live migration, high availability, advanced management tools	Live migration, replication, integration with Windows	Cross-platform, easy to use, supports multiple OSes	Live…source open-source	Highly scalable, known for easy scalability in hyper-converged environments 31	32

These alternatives offer comparable features and performance at a fraction of the cost, making them increasingly attractive options for businesses seeking to reduce their IT expenditure.

Declining Product Quality and Competitiveness

Beyond the licensing costs, there are growing concerns about the decline in VMware’s product quality and competitiveness³³. Broadcom’s focus on cost-cutting has reportedly led to reduced investment in research and development, potentially impacting innovation and product development³⁴. This, combined with the potential exodus of skilled employees after the acquisition, could lead to a decline in product quality and a slower pace of innovation, making VMware less competitive in the long run³⁵.

Customer feedback also points to a decline in support quality³⁷. Users have reported difficulties with the new support portal, including problems with access and navigation, slow response times, and a lack of expertise among support staff³⁷. This decline in support quality further erodes customer trust and satisfaction, potentially driving businesses towards alternative solutions.

Adding to these concerns, users have reported negative experiences with the user interface (UI) of VMware products. Complaints range from difficulties in navigating the new UI to issues with icon visibility and a lack of color, making basic administration more challenging³⁸. Furthermore, there are concerns about the security of VMware products under Broadcom’s ownership, given Broadcom’s history of security breaches³⁹.

Customer Feedback and Reviews

Customer feedback provides valuable insights into the perceived impact of Broadcom’s acquisition on VMware’s products and services. Here’s a summary of customer reviews across different product categories:

VMware Workstation Pro:

• Customers generally praise VMware Workstation Pro for its powerful virtualization capabilities, ease of deployment, and comprehensive features⁴⁰.
• However, some users have reported issues with the user interface, finding it less intuitive for new users⁴¹.

VMware vSphere:

• Customers appreciate vSphere’s performance, scalability, and ease of use⁴².
• However, concerns have been raised about the recent decline in support quality and the increase in licensing costs⁴³.

VMware NSX:

• While customers acknowledge the advanced features and flexibility of NSX, they also point to its complexity and high cost⁴⁴.
• Some users have reported encountering bugs and difficulties with integration⁴⁴.

These reviews highlight a mixed bag of opinions. While VMware’s core technologies are still generally well-regarded, the recent changes under Broadcom’s ownership have clearly impacted customer perception, particularly regarding licensing costs and support quality.

The Future of VMware

The future of VMware hangs in the balance. While the company still holds a significant market share in the virtualization space, the Broadcom acquisition and the subsequent changes in licensing and product strategy have undoubtedly weakened its position⁴⁵. The rise of strong competitors, coupled with the growing popularity of open-source solutions, poses a significant challenge to VMware’s dominance⁴⁶.

Broadcom’s strategy of focusing on profitability and a smaller customer base could create opportunities for competitors like Nutanix⁴⁷. Nutanix, with its simplified infrastructure management, strong focus on hyper-converged infrastructure, and competitive pricing, is well-positioned to attract customers who are dissatisfied with VMware’s new direction. Similarly, open-source solutions, with their flexibility, cost-effectiveness, and strong community support, are becoming increasingly viable alternatives for businesses seeking to reduce their reliance on proprietary software.

Furthermore, the data center virtualization market is evolving rapidly. Key growth drivers include the increasing demand for cloud computing, the growing need for scalable and cost-effective infrastructure solutions, and the expanding use of hybrid environments and edge computing⁴⁸. VMware needs to adapt to these trends and innovate to remain competitive.

To regain its footing, VMware needs to address the concerns of its customers and partners. This includes re-evaluating its licensing model, investing in product innovation, and improving the quality of its customer support²⁵. Whether VMware can successfully navigate these challenges and reclaim its position as the industry leader remains to be seen.

Conclusion

VMware’s journey from an industry pioneer to a company facing decline is a cautionary tale of how even the most dominant players can lose their way. While the company’s innovative technology and strong market position once seemed unassailable, the Broadcom acquisition and the subsequent changes have had a significant impact on its trajectory. The exorbitant licensing costs, declining product quality, and erosion of customer trust have created an opportunity for competitors to gain ground.

The implications of VMware’s decline extend beyond the company itself. It highlights the potential consequences of prioritizing short-term profitability over long-term customer relationships and product innovation. For businesses that rely on VMware’s products, it serves as a reminder of the importance of evaluating alternatives and diversifying their IT infrastructure to mitigate the risks associated with vendor lock-in.

Looking ahead, the virtualization market is poised for continued growth and evolution. The rise of cloud computing, the increasing adoption of hybrid and multi-cloud environments, and the emergence of new technologies like containerization will shape the future of this dynamic industry. Whether VMware can adapt to these changes and regain its former glory, or whether it will become a footnote in the history of virtualization, remains to be seen.

Works cited

1. What is virtualization? | Glossary | HPE, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.hpe.com/us/en/what-is/virtualization.html

2. Greybeard Showoff Day: What was before vmware ESXi? Was there an “inbetween” bare metal and virtualization phase? : r/sysadmin – Reddit, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/18ajdoh/greybeard_showoff_day_what_was_before_vmware_esxi/

3. History of VMware: Evolution Timeline | by NAKIVO – Medium, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://nakivo.medium.com/history-of-vmware-evolution-timeline-6173482c6d21

4. VMware’s first contentious year under Broadcom drives customers to weigh other options, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.ciodive.com/news/broadcom-vmware-acquistion-vcf-private-cloud/733800/

5. VMware turns 25 today, but will it mature or regress? – The Register, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.theregister.com/2023/02/10/vmware_turns_25/

6. The History of NSX and the Future of Network Virtualization – Broadcom News & Stories, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://news.vmware.com/technologies/history-nsx-future-network-virtualization

7. VMware – Wikipedia, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VMware

8. The Hidden Costs of Broadcom’s VMware Acquisition for SMBs | Pogo Tech Blog, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.pogolinux.com/blog/hidden-costs-broadcom-vmware-merger-smbs/

9. vizologi.com, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://vizologi.com/business-strategy-canvas/broadcom-business-model-canvas/#:~:text=Broadcom’s%20unique%20business%20model%20revolves,integrate%20hardware%20and%20software%20seamlessly.

10. www.channelinsider.com, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.channelinsider.com/cloud-computing/broadcom-vmware-acquisition-changes-explained/#:~:text=Broadcom’s%20acquisition%20of%20VMware%20was,provider%20for%20corporate%20IT%20infrastructure.

11. Broadcom’s VMware strategy: A plan that will reshape IT – Digital Sunshine Solutions, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://digitalsunshinesolutions.com/broadcoms-vmware-strategy-a-plan-that-will-reshape-it/

12. Broadcom Completes Acquisition of VMware, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://investors.broadcom.com/news-releases/news-release-details/broadcom-completes-acquisition-vmware

13. How Broadcom Innovations Connect the World, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://docs.broadcom.com/docs/futurum-how-broadcom-innovations-connect-the-world

14. Broadcom’s acquisition of VMware: What you need to know | SoftwareOne blog, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.softwareone.com/en/blog/articles/2024/03/25/broadcoms-acquisition-of-vmware-what-you-need-to-know

15. Deciphering Broadcom’s VMware Acquisition: Licensing Changes For Business Leaders, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://gbq.com/broadcoms-vmware-acquisition-licensing-changes/

16. The Broadcom VMware Acquisition: 2024 Merger Explained – Channel Insider, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.channelinsider.com/cloud-computing/broadcom-vmware-acquisition-changes-explained/

17. Navigating VMware’s Changes Post-Broadcom Acquisition – Connectria, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.connectria.com/resources/navigating-vmwares-changes-post-broadcom-acquisition/

18. The Aftermath of Broadcom’s VMware Acquisition – ClearScale Blog, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://blog.clearscale.com/how-the-broadcom-vmware-acquisition-of-vmware-is-affecting-longtime-customers/

19. VMware Licensing Changes by Broadcom – Details, Implications and Recommendations, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.parkplacetechnologies.com/blog/vmware-licensing-changes-details-implications-recommendations/

20. VMware License Changes after Broadcom’s acquisition – – Redwood Compliance, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.redwoodcompliance.com/vmware-license-changes-after-broadcoms-acquisition/

21. Broadcom VMware Licensing Changes Explained – Redress Compliance, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://redresscompliance.com/broadcom-vmware-licensing-and-subscription-changes-explained/

22. VMware Cost Increases – How Broadcom VMware Product Offerings Are Evolving, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://blogs.idc.com/2024/08/07/vmware-cost-increases-how-broadcom-vmware-product-offerings-are-evolving/

23. Broadcom’s acquisition of VMware: Navigating the turbulences of licensing changes, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://blog.usu.com/en-us/broadcom-vmware-licensing

24. Transformative Changes Since VMware’s Acquisition by Broadcom – Focus Technology, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.focustsi.com/transformative-changes-since-vmwares-acquisition-by-broadcom/

25. to victims of brutal VMware license and partner program changes in EU after Broadcom acquisition – Reddit, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.reddit.com/r/vmware/comments/1bbzy8z/to_victims_of_brutal_vmware_license_and_partner/

26. Broadcoms speculated VMWare strategy to concentrate on their 600 major customers : r/sysadmin – Reddit, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/v111ov/broadcoms_speculated_vmware_strategy_to/

27. v2cloud.com, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://v2cloud.com/blog/vmware-vsphere-licensing-and-costs#:~:text=VMware%20vSphere%20Enterprise%20Plus%20(with,%244780%20per%20CPU%20per%20year.

28. VMware Cost Alternatives: Strategic and Community Insights, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://community.veeam.com/blogs-and-podcasts-57/vmware-cost-alternatives-strategic-and-community-insights-9076

29. VMware vSphere Essentials Plus Kit – SHI, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.shi.com/product/40377362/VMware-vSphere-Essentials-Plus-Kit

30. VMware Licensing Calculator – WintelGuy.com, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://wintelguy.com/vmware-licensing-calc.pl

31. Nutanix vs VMware: Complete Comparison – NAKIVO, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.nakivo.com/blog/vmware-vs-nutanix/

32. Top 11 VMware Alternatives & Competitors for Virtualizing Workloads in 2024, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.acecloudhosting.com/blog/top-vmware-alternatives/

33. Should we be worried about the future of VMWare products? : r …, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1d0c1ae/should_we_be_worried_about_the_future_of_vmware/

34. The Broadcom VMware Acquisition: A Complete Timeline – Channel Futures, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.channelfutures.com/channel-business/the-broadcom-vmware-acquisition-a-complete-timeline

35. VMware Customers: Brace For Impact – Forrester, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.forrester.com/blogs/vmware-customers-brace-for-impact/

36. Decided to decline – sharing the why – post regarding VMware layoffs – TheLayoff.com, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.thelayoff.com/t/1pixX1wZ

37. VMware Support Challenges In 2025: Solutions & Alternatives | V2 Cloud, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://v2cloud.com/blog/vmware-support

38. VMWare software quality is now utterly terrible | vCenter – Broadcom Community, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://community.broadcom.com/vmware-cloud-foundation/discussion/vmware-software-quality-is-now-utterly-terrible

39. Top 5 Concerns & Countermeasures Regarding Broadcom’s Acquisition of VMware, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.netnetweb.com/content/blog/top-5-concerns-countermeasures-regarding-broadcoms-acquisition-of-vmware

40. www.getapp.sg, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.getapp.sg/software/2048254/vmware-workstation-player#:~:text=Powerful%20Virtualization%20Product&text=After%207%2B%20years%20of%20using,find%20in%20other%20competing%20products.

41. VMware Workstation Pro Reviews & Ratings 2024 – TrustRadius, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.trustradius.com/products/vmware-workstation-pro/reviews

42. www.gartner.com, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.gartner.com/reviews/market/it-resilience-orchestration/vendor/broadcom-vmware/product/vsphere#:~:text=Favorable%20Review&text=My%20experience%20with%20vSphere%20has,machine%20which%20reduces%20my%20expenses.

43. Broadcom (VMware) vSphere Reviews, Ratings & Features 2024 | Gartner Peer Insights, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.gartner.com/reviews/market/server-virtualization/vendor/broadcom-vmware/product/vsphere

44. VMware NSX Data Center Reviews – Gartner Peer Insights, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.gartner.com/reviews/market/data-center-and-cloud-networking/vendor/broadcom-vmware/product/vmware-nsx

45. Hypervisor Market Update: Emerging VMware Trends & Alternatives – Rimini Street, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.riministreet.com/blog/hypervisor-market-update-key-insights-on-vmware-trends-alternatives/

46. 1 in 5 VMware customers plan to jump off its stack next year – The Register Forums, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://forums.theregister.com/forum/all/2023/11/08/vmware_customer_forrester_prediction/

47. Assessing Broadcom-VMware eight months on – SiliconANGLE, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://siliconangle.com/2024/08/18/assessing-broadcom-vmware-eight-months/

48. Data Center Virtualization Market to Reach USD 28.9 Billion by 2032, Driven by the Growing Need for Scalable, Cost-Effective Infrastructure Solutions | Research by SNS Insider – GlobeNewswire, accessed on December 18, 2024, https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2024/12/06/2993074/0/en/Data-Center-Virtualization-Market-to-Reach-USD-28-9-Billion-by-2032-Driven-by-the-Growing-Need-for-Scalable-Cost-Effective-Infrastructure-Solutions-Research-by-SNS-Insider.html